How Do The Other Dwarves Feel About Bilbo's Banishment

How Do the Other Dwarves Feel About Bilbo's Banishment? Exploring the Aftermath of The Hobbit

The tale of Bilbo Baggins, the unlikely hobbit who journeyed with thirteen dwarves to reclaim Erebor, is one of adventure, courage, and unexpected friendship. Yet, the narrative's satisfying conclusion leaves a lingering question: how did the dwarves truly feel about Bilbo's self-imposed exile after their triumphant return? While Tolkien doesn't explicitly detail their individual reactions, we can infer their sentiments based on their characterizations, their relationships with Bilbo, and the overall implications of his departure. This exploration delves into the complex emotions likely swirling within the dwarven company following Bilbo's decision, examining their potential responses with sensitivity and nuance.

The Initial Shock and Disbelief

Bilbo's sudden departure after the reclaiming of Erebor would undoubtedly have been a shock. For thirteen dwarves who had endured a perilous journey relying on Bilbo's ingenuity and unexpected bravery, his absence would leave a void. The initial reaction would likely have been a mixture of surprise and confusion. Thorin, even in his final moments, had shown a grudging respect and affection for Bilbo. His death, while tragic, left a leadership vacuum, and the sudden disappearance of the hobbit who had proven invaluable to their quest would intensify their sense of loss and disorientation.

The Perspective of Fili and Kili

Fili and Kili, the nephews of Thorin who formed a particularly strong bond with Bilbo, would likely feel the absence most acutely. Their youthful enthusiasm and playful nature found a kindred spirit in Bilbo, creating a genuine friendship that transcended their initial expectations. The loss of Bilbo would represent not only the end of an adventure but also the severing of a cherished connection. Their grief over Thorin's death would be compounded by the unexpected departure of their newfound friend, leaving them with a profound sense of emptiness.

Grief and a Sense of Loss

Beyond the initial shock, the dwarves would likely experience a deeper sense of loss. Bilbo was more than just a burglar; he was the unlikely hero who turned the tide of their desperate quest. He was the one who discovered the Arkenstone, the key to their reconciliation with the Elves and their eventual victory. His contribution to the reclaiming of Erebor wasn't just logistical; he provided much needed levity and emotional support during moments of despair and doubt.

The Unseen Impact of Bilbo's Courage

Many of the dwarves, especially those initially skeptical of Bilbo's abilities, would eventually come to appreciate his courage and resourcefulness. His unexpected bravery and strategic thinking saved them on countless occasions. Dwalin's initial gruffness would likely give way to a recognition of Bilbo’s indispensable role in their success. Balin, the wise and thoughtful dwarf, would surely understand the weight of Bilbo’s decision and its impact on his emotional state. The loss of such a valuable member of their company, regardless of his species, would undoubtedly leave a melancholic void.

Understanding Bilbo's Reasons: Empathy and Acceptance?

The dwarves' understanding of Bilbo’s reasons for leaving would significantly shape their reaction. Bilbo's self-imposed exile wasn’t a rejection of them; it was a response to the profound changes he had undergone and the desire to return to a life he thought he had lost. A mature response from the dwarves would be one of empathy, even if tinged with disappointment.

The Role of Dís and the Female Perspective

Dís, Thorin's sister, represents a voice of reason and maternal instinct within the dwarven company. Her perspective on Bilbo’s departure is crucial. As a strong and insightful character, she would likely understand Bilbo’s need for solitude and the transformative nature of his journey. While sad to see him go, she might offer quiet understanding and acceptance of his decision, encouraging the other dwarves to respect his choice.

The Lingering Bond of Friendship: Continued Connections

Despite the separation, the bond forged between Bilbo and the dwarves during their adventure wouldn't easily be broken. Bilbo's legacy within the dwarven community would endure, influencing their lives long after his departure. Letters, gifts, and perhaps even occasional visits would serve as reminders of their shared experiences and the lasting friendship forged in the heart of the Lonely Mountain.

A Legacy of Shared Experience

The dwarves' stories of their journey with the "burglar" would become legendary within their community. Bilbo's bravery and resourcefulness would be recounted as an essential element of their victory, making him a figure of enduring respect and affection. The tales would become part of the dwarven oral tradition, ensuring that Bilbo's contribution to their reclamation of Erebor would never be forgotten.

The Long-Term Effects on the Dwarves' Community

Bilbo's absence would leave a lasting impact on the dwarves' community in Erebor. His unique perspective, his kindness, and his willingness to bridge cultural divides would be missed. The dwarves' rebuilding efforts would be subtly influenced by the values that Bilbo unknowingly instilled in their society.

A Legacy of Tolerance and Understanding

Bilbo's presence had helped to break down some of the barriers and prejudices between the dwarves and the other races. His friendship with Gandalf, the Elves, and even Beorn, would leave a lasting impact on the dwarves' worldview. They would eventually embrace a more tolerant and understanding approach toward other races, a legacy that would continue long after Bilbo's departure.

Conclusion: A bittersweet farewell

Bilbo's banishment was not an act of betrayal, but rather a poignant reflection of his journey's transformative power. While the dwarves would undoubtedly feel a profound sense of loss, their mature response would likely be one of understanding and acceptance. Their shared experiences would continue to bind them, and the memory of their unlikely companion would become part of their treasured history, shaping their future relationships and their outlook on the world. The impact of Bilbo’s journey was not limited to his personal growth, it significantly shaped the hearts and minds of the thirteen dwarves who shared in his extraordinary adventure. The tale of their friendship stands as a testament to the power of unexpected bonds and the lasting impact of even a temporary companionship. Their memories would be a constant reminder of the courage, kindness and wisdom of the hobbit who had helped them reclaim their ancestral home.